Who Comments on the Commentators?
So, this Olympics I’ve fallen hard for the ice skating. Don’t worry, it’ll be over in a week and change, and then we’ll be back to pictures of horrific advertising as per usual.
The men’s short program was last night, and I have a couple of comments, mostly regarding the commentators and editorializing.
1. The commenting in general was hugely over the top, as with Florent Amodio, whom they treated as if he was a salamander because he had been adopted from Brazil to France, and no adoptee has ever come to anything until this moment, I guess. Not particularly offensive, just…really pushing the bullet points on their notes.
2. Plushenko. Okay, here is the thing about Plushenko. Do I think he’s a jerk? Yes. Do I think his skating lacks artistry? Yes. Am I glad two other skaters have put in performances that will make the long program an honest fight? Yes. Do I think that, if Plushenko gets the gold, Russia will come and get us? No, I do not, because I am a person with a functioning brain stem.
Just – for god’s sake, paint him as a jerk in your fluff piece if you want, it’s not hard; but skip the ominous smash cuts to barbed wire and crumbling statues and imposing architecture, all right, NBC? I mean, BOND movies are ashamed of you, that’s how bad this is.
3. The NBC commentators, including the usually-excellent Scott Hamilton, seemed shocked that Johnny Weir delivered a solid performance, despite a very long list of competitive wins. I understand his program lacked the technical difficulty of some of the other skaters’, so there wasn’t the thrill that a quad brings, but they seemed amazed that he did anything besides mince in a circle. You heard a lot of comments like, “It’s funny because, as controversial as he is, he really is a purist when it comes to technique – his technique is fine.”
This annoys me because it’s disingenuous on the part of the commentators, who have been aware of his career for many years and should maybe be a little less surprised by his technique, and also because a comment like that assumes flamboyant men can’t take something seriously, which, really?
For anyone who doesn’t want to sit through all the awful, endless footage of dudes falling down last night, my three personal-favorite routines, in skate order:
1. Florent Amodio. (If this kid doesn’t have a medal eight years from now, I’d like to know why.)
2. Daisuke Takahashi. (If he doesn’t have a medal 24 hours from now, I’d like to know why.)











